Hypothetical: if you had 10 uninterrupted minutes with a psilocybin researcher — someone like Griffiths, Carhart-Harris, or Johnson — what would you ask them that you can't find answered in the published literature or interviews?
Reply #1 · ▲ 103 upvotes
I'd ask: what do you personally believe psilocybin is doing — mechanistically, psychologically, philosophically? Not what the data says, but what you think is actually happening. The published literature is careful and measured. I want to know what someone who has spent 20 years studying this actually believes, in the moments when they're not writing for peer review.
Reply #2 · ▲ 89 upvotes
My question: why does the mystical experience predict outcomes so strongly across conditions as different as depression, addiction, and cancer anxiety? Is there something specific about the nature of mystical experience that's therapeutic, or is mystical experience just a proxy for how strong was the session? I've never found this fully answered.
Reply #3 · ▲ 74 upvotes
Practical one: what do you tell people who come to you having already had multiple high-dose experiences without integration and who haven't benefited — or who feel worse? The literature covers naive subjects in controlled settings. What happens with the long-term psychedelic user who isn't getting what they hoped for?
86 more replies — forum posting coming soon.
← Back to General Discussion